Page 1 of 1

Fluctuating download speed

Posted: May 13th, 2016, 4:57 am
by flash3d
After upgrading to 300 mbit cable from 200 mbit ,I noticed that my download was fluctuating between 14 ~ 35 MB/sec.
Ruling out all the other options (provider, news server) I decided to change the following two settings under General/Tuning:
Maximum line speed (34M)
Percentage of line speed (100)

With the above setting I finally get a stable download of 34 MB/sec.
On my previous speed (200 mbit) I had both of these settings empty and speed was always maxed out.

Can anybody explain this behavior?

ps I should be able to get a little better download speed (around 36~40 MB/sec) but when raising the Maximum line speed to 35m I get the fluctuating speeds again.

update: Something is not working like it should, now I have speeds again between 10 and 25 MB/sec. When trying the same NZB with NZBget I'm getting speeds between 34 and 38 MB/sec.

Re: Fluctuating download speed

Posted: May 13th, 2016, 5:20 am
by safihre
Yes, SABnzbd is the problem. Specifically the decoder of the articles.
After an article is downloaded, it needs to be decoded to become part of the final file. At a certain point decoding just cannot keep up with the downloading and SABnzbd will throttle the download speed for a few seconds, this is the behavior you're seeing. It will go up and down and up and down. Seems 34MB/s was the balance for your setup.
Some downloads have different article sizes, so the decoder might be slower/faster on some downloads.

We have some improvements for SABnzbd 1.1.0 which will imrpove speeds, but might still be a few months out for final release. At these speeds NZBGet programming language (C++) just outperforms Python when doing the decoding and assembling. We try to make the best of it!

Re: Fluctuating download speed

Posted: May 13th, 2016, 7:43 am
by flash3d
Thanks, would a faster CPU help? Using a 7 year old AMD Phenom II X4.

Re: Fluctuating download speed

Posted: May 13th, 2016, 9:21 am
by safihre
It would, but for now nzbget might be the better solution. Until we can really push more out of Sabnzbd.

Re: Fluctuating download speed

Posted: June 11th, 2016, 4:00 am
by flash3d
Did some tests but SABnzbd 1.1.0 bèta 1 download seems to be on par with nzbget now! (stable around 36mb/sec).
Thanks!!